1 Comments December 5, 2024

TCL's AI Push: Hype or Substance?

Advertisements

The Consumer Electronics Show (CES) of 2025 has evolved into a showcase that could aptly be termed the "AI Spring Festival." With the electric presence of NVIDIA's CEO, Jensen Huang, dazzling in his vibrant jacket, and a plethora of AI innovations ranging from over 300 AI-enabled glasses to an array of smart home devices and robotics, it's clear that Artificial Intelligence has taken center stageThe event marks the two-year anniversary of ChatGPT, a milestone that signals AI's shift from a niche interest to a fundamental platform reshaping industriesWhether it's in the cloud or at the edge, AI's proliferation is unmistakable and represents the dominant theme of the 2025 CES.

Before Huang's illuminating address, TCL, the largest exhibiting Chinese brand at CES, captured significant attentionThe company showcased a wide variety of products, revealing an All-in-AI strategy that appears to be one of its core strategies moving forward

On January 6, TCL's founder, Li Dongsheng, made headlines by announcing that the company would unveil 25 major product categories featuring over 120 technology products, with a particular emphasis on their latest advancements in AI applications and developmentsBack in December, during their Global Technology Innovation Conference (TIC2024), TCL introduced a comprehensive AI smart operating system alongside various AI-driven appliances such as intelligent refrigerators, air conditioners, televisions, and learning devices.

The landscape of tech and manufacturing businesses has traditionally been quite distinctXiaomi, for instance, transitioned from a pure manufacturing image through years of smartphone development and the success of its electric vehiclesToday, TCL seems eager to replicate that trajectory using AI, but the path ahead is undoubtedly fraught with challenges.

Embracing AI is not as straightforward as it may appear

Companies like Apple and Tesla have set the bar high, while newer entrants such as Li Auto and Xiaomi add to the competitionThe trend is unmistakable; however, seizing such opportunities requires more than basic arithmeticAlthough TCL possesses a robust manufacturing foundation and supply chain capabilities, their current understanding and integration of AI seem less than convincingThe aggressive approach they are taking might conjure memories of TCL's earlier, bold mergers during the renewable energy boom, which eventually turned into pitfalls.

TCL has built a reputation for capitalizing on stock market trends and aligning itself with technological movements, yet the question arises whether it can realize meaningful transformation and empowerment amidst this rushPresently, TCL's photovoltaic business finds itself back in the loss column, while its traditional panel production languishes at the bottom of the cycle, bearing the challenges of meager profit margins

Although TCL's AI appliances division has shown rapid growth, it seems more like a product of timing than strategic foresightExternal factors like AI advancement, global inflation, and domestic appliance upgrades signal changes in market conditionsInternally, significant mergers only took place by 2023, rebranding their white goods under TCL Smart Home, suggesting a fragmented ecosystem that has yet to achieve synergy.

TCL's journey is reminiscent of an experienced traveler navigating through a familiar but challenging pathAs they race forward, embracing AI as a new direction, they also evoke a rich history of trial and effortTCL has amassed experience over the years, yet whether it can successfully transition into this new era remains uncertain.

When evaluating the product landscape presented at CES, one can gauge the true ambitions of different companiesTCL unveiled an extensive product lineup comprising over 100 innovative technology achievements spanning various sectors, including televisions, gaming displays, tablets, smartphones, AR glasses, automotive screens, air conditioning units, refrigerators, washing machines, AI robots, smart door locks, security cameras, automotive cockpit solutions, and smart energy solutions for homes.

The showcase closely mirrored TCL's December announcements during the TIC2024 as the company demonstrated various AI-enabled devices

alefox

However, its AI-centric technical content emphasized five key areas: intelligent operations, AI simulations, a central model for smart home scenarios, AI movie production, and the Star Intelligence X-Intelligence 2.0 innovationsTogether, these elements represented TCL's vision for a comprehensive, end-to-end AI application solution.

It becomes evident from these five AI focal points that TCL is intent on optimizing existing workflows—enhancing product interactions, design processes, performance improvement, content production, and manufacturing efficiencyNotably, this trajectory bears similarities to Xiaomi's earlier "AIoT" conceptTCL's focus lies more in refining the established chain rather than introducing disruptive technologiesObservational insights from demonstration videos reveal tangible changes, such as voice recognition and intelligent recommendations—albeit reminiscent of features unveiled by products like the Nut TNT workstation back in 2018, raising questions about the originality of these innovations.

Amidst all this, economic data reveals that only six appliance companies made the 2023 Fortune Global 500 list, highlighting the competition

Samsung led with $240 billion in revenue, followed by Sony at approximately $85 billion, LG Electronics at about $65 billion, and Panasonic around $62 billionIn contrast, domestic titans Midea and Haier recorded far lesser revenue figures totaling $514 billion and $362 billion, squarely below Samsung's performance.

Notably, Samsung is not a conventional home appliance manufacturer but benefits significantly from its established semiconductor and mobile segments, which provide leverage across its varied product linesThis savvy integration allows Samsung to maintain around 30% of sales in the global television market and dominate larger formats where their market share is nearly 50%. Moreover, they hold roughly 20% market share in the highly competitive US appliances domain, showcasing their leadership in refrigerators and washing machines.

TCL, then, appears to be mirroring Samsung’s industrial strategies while drawing inspiration from Sony's multifaceted approach

Sony's commercial model, for instance, is heavily reliant on media and entertainment, bolstering its hardware sales as each segment complements the otherThis synergy has allowed Sony to stand out in competitive arenas within the appliance industry.

In a notable move, TCL has strategically highlighted AI film production and actively pushes to enhance its content capabilitiesIn November of 2024, the TCL Chinese Theatre in Hollywood premiered five short films generated by established writers and directors on the TCL AI content creation platform—an early glimpse into the potential of AI within cinematic creationLooking forward to 2025, TCL intends to launch its first 90-minute AI film in North America, representing a significant initiative to evolve AI applications into the creative sectors of film and entertainment.

Ultimately, through leveraging AI as a strategic foundation and emulating paths forged by both Samsung and Sony, TCL's overarching ambition seems clear: to redefine their position in the competitive landscape of technology and maintain relevance.

Yet, despite the clarity of their strategy, the success likelihood becomes a critical factor determining whether TCL can carve out a niche in the burgeoning field of AI

Although known for high-end manufacturing, TCL's association with AI is relatively freshReports indicate that since Q4 of 2022, TCL has explored various large models while launching AI-integrated productsHowever, when examining the innovations that have emerged, the integration of AI features within their products often falls short of revolutionary—a juxtaposition of chatbot interfaces with televisions and smart climate control functionalities, leading to an impression of minor incremental progress rather than disruptive innovation.

Theoretically, due to its vast product line and varied technical assets, creating a cohesive brand identity for TCL proves challengingThe company's integration of AI across different divisions reveals distinguishing characteristics that might hinder a unified approach, reflecting concerns over whether TCL can transition from an IoT-oriented strategy to a genuine embrace of AI technology—a sentiment informed by Xiaomi's initial strides in AIoT that were more about refining existing products than pioneering breakthroughs.

Moreover, TCL's stronghold rests within its panel production capabilities, evidenced by the introduction of the X11K QD-Mini LED TV, hailed for its cutting-edge technology and enhanced display features, such as 14,000 local dimming zones and peak brightness ratings of up to 6,500 nits

This feat reinforces TCL's mastery in manufacturing; however, the implementation of AI features within its television products seems somewhat simplified, focusing on integrating Google’s Gemini AI model for anticipated releases in 2025.

While promising AI integrations abound, TCL's competitive edge remains primarily rooted in manufacturing rather than AI-tech advancementThe symbiotic relationship expected between traditional panel strengths and AI applications appears lacking in tangible transformation.

Moreover, TCL's purported focus on AI filmmaking captures light amid broader industry constraintsReports indicate that TCL used AI tools like ComfyUI, Nuke, and Runway for production, but notable contributions came from human involvement—experienced screenwriters, directors, and composers added a layer of artistry to these pieces.

During film showcases, Chris Regina, TCL’s head of North American content, outlined how over 50 contributors provided expertise in animation, editing, visual effects, and scientific research for the film projects

TCL's high-volume sales stemming from its TVs serve as the backbone driving engagement, but it's evident they currently rely on external creative expertise rather than being a maven in original content production.

This reality underscores TCL’s role more as a content producer rather than a leader in technological or creative fieldsThe company rests at a relatively nascent development stage, its reliance on their overseas distribution to generate positive feedback illustrates an attempt to harness market flow rather than establishing a potent, independent presence.

Very much, TCL appears to treat AI as a conceptual layer rather than a transformative force—a pattern visible across manufacturing, product-centric approaches, and content developmentThough the early trials seem promising, ATCL’s engagement with AI remains a mix of basic functionalities boosting performance without fundamentally reshaping their services.

In the context of navigating contemporary market dynamics, this strategy of incorporating AI seems sensible given the reduced risk and enhanced speed of integration

Yet, as leading enterprises either pivot fully into AI or develop robust strategies, TCL must contend with the stark reality of distinguishing itself within the now-crowded AI and IoT ecosystemsAs Li Xiang, founder of Li Auto, stated, the essence of AI lies in enhancing capabilities rather than just functionality improvement—prompting a crucial inquiry for TCL regarding the role AI will play in their future.

The crux of TCL’s dilemma lies in whether they will emerge victorious from the AI transformation or find themselves entrapped in a multi-faceted competitive webWith TCL positioned as a frontrunner within the end-to-end industry ecosystem, its legacy in panel manufacturing forms a robust foundation for the company moving forwardHowever, the integration of AI into consumer appliances like intelligent air conditioning and refrigerators calls for agile adaptation from existing manufacturing advantages to capitalize on new market trends.

Nevertheless, TCL faces the specter of a considerable gamble as well

While built on a manufacturing legacy, the company’s journey into AI tech demands them to bridge a secondary position within the value chainCompeting giants such as Google and Microsoft command significant advantages with their advanced algorithms and processing capabilitiesEven peer competitors like Samsung and Sony hold imposing leverageIn this scenario, AI model training requires massive data processing and computational prowess; any sluggishness could result in TCL's AI offerings relegated to a lower tier, unable to match precision in intelligent interactions or content relevance—a worrying prospect that could encumber TCL in a challenging market scenario.

Consumer adoption further complicates the landscape, as the acclimation to AI appliances continues to unfoldDespite favorable market dynamics from governmental incentives, brands will need to navigate consumer apprehensions associated with complexities in AI functionalities and potential functionality confusion

Additionally, the cost implications resulting from AI integration could hinder competitive pricing and positioning, rendering a serious challenge in balancing expense and consumer pricing amidst rapid technological advancement.

The competitive arena is saturated with bombs from tech powerhouses and appliance titans amplifying their AIoT strategiesEstablished brands like Midea and Haier possess advantageous expertise and vast user basesContemporary rivals such as Xiaomi and Huawei are leveraging their brand strength across smart home solutions to invade traditional appliance territoriesWhether TCL can redefine its identity and create differentiation in tomorrow's market amidst surging pressures remains a paramount considerationStrategic maneuvers in product uniqueness, platform openness, and customer experiences will be critical—failure to innovate creatively could result in TCL's struggle within the expanding AI landscape, causing the promised transformation to remain an illusion.

According to Li Dongsheng, no business decision comes without risk; a failure to innovate may lead to obsolescence